Ward 6 — York Centre
About the Ward
Ward 6, York Centre, is roughly bordered by Steeles Avenue West to the north, Bathurst Street to the east, Highway 401 to the south, and Jane and Keele Street to the west. At $86,717, the average household income in the ward is below the city average ($102,721). The population is 104,320. The area is slightly less diverse than Toronto: 46 per cent of people are visible minorities, compared to 51 per cent for the city as a whole. Current councillor James Pasternak has served on council since 2010.
Where the Candidates Stand
Pasternak may be one of the longest serving councillors, but a small field of candidates is mounting a strong challenge. Mike Arkin, a progressive, is running on a platform of improved road safety and housing affordability. Hope Schrier is courting the youth vote—she’s a content creator with 6,500 followers on social media.
The matrix below provides a head-to-head comparison of where council candidates stand. The Local combed through city council records to review all the decisions made over the last four years and identified a dozen votes that are the most telling on key issues: homelessness, transportation, housing, policing, taxes, and the environment. We then asked all candidates to participate in a survey on how they would have voted on those same 12 motions, adding their responses to Pasternak’s votes.
Two of the three candidates—Arkin and Schrier—responded to The Local’s survey.
Here Are the Takeaways
- The youth candidate, Schrier, voted along the lines of the much more senior John Tory. She doesn’t support raising property taxes or enacting a personal vehicle tax (though she would hike property taxes to support a TTC fare freeze).
- The only issue that all three candidates are aligned on, along with the mayor, is introducing a stormwater charge.
- Arkin, who does not support toilets in encampments, notes that he thinks more housing is the solution, not more policing.
Read Our Election Stories:
Toronto Election 2022
Ongoing coverage of Toronto’s 2022 municipal election. In-depth features on the issues at stake, hyper-local coverage of competitive ward races across the city, and a Candidate Tracker tool to keep you informed this fall.
Everything You Need to Know About School Trustees
We don’t elect people to oversee any other specific public service. But maybe we should?
Call the Police… Then Wait
The Toronto Police take three times longer than they should to get to the most urgent emergencies. Why a $1.1 billion force doesn’t come when you need them.
Pulled Off Wheel-Trans and Forced onto the Subway
Cost-cutting measures will push thousands of paratransit users onto the TTC, with disabled and elderly riders forced into gruelling bus and subway trips.
How Toronto’s Councillors Became Nearly Unbeatable
The numbers don’t lie: this city’s incumbency advantage is the worst in North America.
City Council Candidates
Mike Arkin
Mike Arkin describes himself as having a background in psychology and computer science, and has previously worked as a TDSB teacher and a consultant, among other roles. He was involved in the founding of the Coalition for Lesbian and Gay Rights in Ontario, and represents transit advocacy group TTCriders at id8 Downsview, a community collaboration working to imagine the future of land use and urban planning in Downsview. His platform includes improved road safety through reduced speed limits and inclusive street design, better and more reliable TTC service with priority lanes and signalling for buses, and universal 24-hour transit service. His housing affordability plans mention more inclusionary zoning and the right to build low- and mid-rise apartments for families. Arkin says he supports raising taxes to maintain city services and infrastructure, and that as taxes grow, the city should provide support to lower-income businesses and people who could be negatively impacted. He describes himself as “against encampments”, but says the solution is housing rather than policing.
Basil Canning
On his website, Basil Canning writes about his experience working in the construction industry, having worked on several public works projects in the Greater Toronto Area. He also notes he is a member of the Ironworkers Union Local 721 and Local 183 Labourers Union. As part of his platform, Canning wants to incentivize growth in rental and development properties by ensuring investment properties are taxed higher unless rented or leased, and putting the funds towards developing additional rental properties. He also wants to support green initiatives, address traffic congestion, speed up city transit improvement initiatives, and improve police-community relationships by encouraging the city to take on issues like homelessness, mental health and addiction. Canning has also previously expressed his support for healthcare and frontline workers and social distancing during the pandemic, as well as concern for the unhoused.
James Pasternak - Incumbent
James Pasternak has been the incumbent city councillor for York Centre since 2010. He sits on several of the city’s boards and committiees such as the mayor’s executive committee, as chair of both the infrastructure and environment committee, and the North York community council. During his term, Pasternak has worked with residents to ease traffic congestion in his ward and protect commuter parking. Pasternak has also proposed motions to make bike share more accessible, to allocate more resources to the Toronto police to battle a spike in hate crimes in 2020, and to expand the eligiblity of property tax, waste, and solid water relief programs. He supported motions to reaffirm the city’s opposition to Quebec’s Bill 21 and reallocate funds to lower TTC fare for post-secondary students. Pasternak has spoken against a motion to allow drinking in public parks. He has voted against motions to rename Dundas street and to review Toronto’s winter maintenance plan to include more Toronto sidewalks in the sidewalk clearing program. Prior to being elected as councillor, Pasternak was a TDSB trustee from 2006 to 2010 where he helped establish Toronto’s only Africentric school. Pasternak has expressed his support for Israel and against the Palestinian Boycott Divest Sanction (BDS) movement. In 2013, Pasternak offered Pride Toronto a “diversity bonus” if it banned Queers Against Israeli Apartheid (QuAIA) from its annual parade. Pasternak has been endorsed by the Toronto Star.
Hope Schrier
Hope Schrier is a student at Toronto Metropolitan University studying creative industries with hopes of a career in publicity and promotion. Schrier currently works at Garage and is a content creator on Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube with over 6,500 combined followers. She has stated on her Instagram that she has wanted to run for mayor since grade 5 and running for councillor is the first step. Schrier’s platform prioritizes safety and cleanliness in the area as well as new schools, making mental health services more accessible, stopping anti-semitism, and taking care of local wildlife.
School Trustee Candidates
Nick Balaskas
Nick Balaskas was a professor in York University’s physics department. According to the Toronto Star, he was dismissed by the university in 2016 for writing and sharing anti-Semitic Facebook posts, a decision later upheld by a labour arbitrator. He also ran for MPP of the York Centre riding as an Ontario Party candidate in the 2022 provincial elections, placing fifth out of nine candidates.
Angela Brandt
Angela Brandt is the president of the Ontario Autism Coalition, an organization that secures effective, funded services for individuals with autism and families. She holds an honours bachelor of science and a master of arts from the University of Toronto, and a post-graduate diploma in research. On her campaign website, Brandt says she deeply understands how challenging navigating the school system can be because she started advocating 15 years ago for services for her son, who was diagnosed with autism at 19 months of age. While details about her campaign online are limited, Brandt says she wants to ensure equity, diversity and inclusivity in the TDSB, that she will be highly accessible to the community and parents, and will fight for the needs of students and schools. Brandt has also been endorsed by the Toronto & York Region Labour Council.
Senai Iman
Senai Iman is a Toronto lawyer who previously ran for Ward 19 trustee in the 2018 municipal elections. He placed last with 500 votes. In 2018, he became an Ontario Living Wage Network supporter. While there is limited information regarding Iman’s current campaign, his platform in 2018 prioritised funding for school infrastructure needs like adequate heating and cooling. To do this, he proposed making an amendment to the Education Act which would allow the TDSB to collect Education Development Charges from developers, for which he created a petition for trustee candidates to commit to. He also proposed the alternative of changing the board’s severe weather policy to close schools when the weather is not suitable for a safe learning environment.
Agnes Kaufman
Information about this candidate could not be found at time of publication.
Nigel Mohammed
While there was limited information online regarding Mohammed’s campaign at the time of publication, a 2019 Pleasant Public School newsletter notes a person by the name of Nigel Mohammed and his involvement on a committee on the creation of a playground.
Rowena Morin
Information about this candidate could not be found at time of publication.
Anthony Pittelli
Information about this candidate could not be found at time of publication.
Alexandra Lulka Rotman - Incumbent
Alexandra Lulka Rotman is the incumbent trustee for Ward 5, having held the position since 2016. On her Twitter profile, she describes herself as a Montessori teacher, as well as a “proud Israel advocate.” Lulka Rotman is also an alumna of the Canadian Jewish Political Affairs Committee. In 2021, she was investigated by the board for breaching the code of conduct after she shared a statement on Twitter regarding distributed materials on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, which she claims were antisemitic. The investigator recommended censure after finding her in violation of the code but trustees voted to reject the recommendation. More recently in February 2022, she made a statement on Facebook in response to antisemitic incidents at a school in her ward. As part of her campaign, Lulka Rotman says she wants to fight hate and anti-semitism in public schools and for more accountability from the TDSB.
Nicola Simpson
Nicola Simpson is the Founder and CEO of the Roxy and Lascelles Simpson Foundation, a not-for-profit focused on community building. Simpson was called to the Ontario Bar in 2022 and earned a Juris Doctor at University of Ottawa – Common Law Section. According to her website, Simpson completed her final year at York University’s Osgoode Law School in 2021 and is currently a Student-at-Law at the Barbra Schlifer Commemorative Clinic. Having lived experience with homelessness and homophobia, Simpson uses her platform to advocate for a safe and equitable learning environment and a diverse and inclusive curriculum and support systems. As part of her campaign, Simpson wants to direct more resources and funding toward addressing student mental health, the inclusion of all students, and systems and policies to combat cyberbullying. In addition, Simpson wants to see more funding for maintenance of schools, to develop measures that safeguard schools and students from future economic uncertainties, and to improve communication between parents, teachers, and trustees.
Gianfranco Cristiano
According to his website, Gianfranco Cristiano is an active community member with over 22 years of customer service experience. He previously ran for Ward 5 TCDSB trustee in 2018, placing second out of five. As part of his campaign, Cristiano wants to preserve international languages programs, address the lack of school bus drivers, and create a program to address poor Maths and English Testing results. He also says he will advocate for smaller classrooms, increase teachers and staff, and fight for funding for outdoor play spaces and special education. Cristiano has been endorsed by the Toronto & York Region Labour Council.
Phil Hornak
Phil Hornak has previously participated in the parent council for Loretto Abbey Secondary School, and has authored a letter that criticized of a number of issues within the TCDSB, including the board’s communication with parents, trustees’ conduct on social media, and what he claimed was a lack of accountability and integrity standards around trustee conduct, though he did not list any specific examples. In 2018, Hornak ran for TCDSB trustee in Ward 6, placing third out of three candidates.
Domenic Rizzo
Information about this candidate could not be found at time of publication.
Maria Rizzo - Incumbent
Maria Rizzo has been the TCDSB trustee for Ward 5, first elected in 2003. She was elected as a North York Board of Education trustee in 1982 and a North York city councillor in 1991, serving two terms. At different times during her tenure as trustee, she served as chair and vice-chair of the Toronto Catholic District School Board. In 2011, as chair, she helped propel the board’s Equity and Inclusion Education policy and in 2019, she was a vocal supporter of a motion to include the terms ‘gender identity’ and ‘gender expression’ in the board’s code of conduct.
Benoit Fortin - Incumbent
Benoit Fortin is the incumbent trustee for Conseil scolaire Viamonde Ward 2 – Est. He has held office since 2018, and has been elected by acclamation in this year’s election given he was running unopposed. Fortin is the founding member and Vice President of Development in Africa and India of Skypower, which develops, funds and runs utility-scale renewable power projects internationally. He is also vice-president of the Association des conseils scolaires des écoles publiques de l’Ontario board of directors, which represents all French-language public school boards in the province. While there is limited information about his priorities, Fortin has commented publicly as vice-president of the board on the importance of keeping students in the francophone school system until grade 12 and of meeting the specific needs of a growing francophone community following an announcement of funding from the Ontario government to build a new school.
Nathalie Dufour Séguin - Incumbent
Nathalie Dufour Séguin is the incumbent trustee for MonAvenir Ward 3 – Toronto Ouest and has been re-elected by acclamation for the 2022 term as she is running unopposed. She was first elected trustee by ballot vote in 2006 and received acclamation in 2010. In 2014, she decided to step down to pursue other projects and was re-elected by ballot vote in 2018. Outside of the TCDSB, Dufour Séguin is an Education Community Relationship Manager for Groupe Média TFO, a media company that generates educational and cultural content for the Ontario Francophone community. She is also a former board member and former president of Toronto Francophone Women’s Shelter La Maison d’hébergement francophone de Toronto.
Dufour Séguin is on the MonAvenir School Council, having originally joined in 2006 when she became trustee (when the school was named Conseil scolaire de district catholique Centre-Sud). After serving as vice president for two years, she was elected president in 2012, a role she held until 2014. In 2013, under Dufour Séguin’s leadership, the school council launched a discrimination action against the province as a means of forcing the Ministry of Education to replace one of their Hamilton-based schools with a new, larger building for the expanded student population. An issue Dufour Séguin said people have been advocating for since the 1990’s, the council invoked charter rights by arguing the Francophone school was not being resourced adequately and therefore access to education was not equal to those in Anglophone schools.
_____
Information in Candidate Tracker was compiled and written by The Local’s team of journalists and fact checkers. City council candidates were emailed a questionnaire asking for information about their history, experience, and plans. They were also surveyed about their stances on twelve key votes that took place in the 2018-22 council term. Not all candidates were reachable or responded. The Local also conducted its own research to independently source and verify information about each city council and school trustee candidate. If you’re a candidate whose information is not here, please email us at elections@thelocal.to. Last updated: October 11, 2022.
Contributors: Inori Roy, Ann Marie Elpa, Nikky Manfredi, Danielle Orr, H.G. Watson, Emma Buchanan, Dhriti Gupta, Zeahaa Rehman, Neville Park, Nicholas Hune-Brown, Tai Huynh, Craig Madho, Steve Combes, and Lia Mattacchione.
Local Journalism Matters.
We're able to produce impactful, award-winning journalism thanks to the generous support of readers. By supporting The Local, you're contributing to a new kind of journalism—in-depth, non-profit, from corners of Toronto too often overlooked.
Support