Ward 24 — Scarborough-Guildwood
About the Ward
Scarborough-Guildwood is bordered by Highway 401 to the north, Morningside Avenue to the east, Markham Road, Bellamy Road, and McCowan Road to the west, and Lake Ontario to the south. It includes the neighbourhoods of Guildwood, West Hill, Morningside, Woburn, and Scarborough Village. Visible minorities make up 71 percent of the ward’s population, with one out of every three residents being South Asian. At $72,289, the ward has a lower household income than the city average ($102,721). Incumbent councillor Paul Ainslie was first elected to city council in 2006.
Where the Candidates Stand
There are four candidates in the race for the Scarborough-Guildwood city council seat, including incumbent Paul Ainslie, who was re-elected easily in the 2018 with 67 percent of the votes. He is facing three challengers, Habiba Desai, Vivian Parker, and Keiosha Ross (see their fact-checked bios in the next section).
The matrix below provides a head-to-head comparison of where council candidates stand on key issues. The Local combed through city council records to review all the decisions made over the last four years and identified a dozen votes that are the most telling on different issues: homelessness, transportation, housing, policing, taxes, and the environment. We then sent the challengers a survey asking them how they would have voted on those same 12 motions, adding the results to what we already know about how Ainslie voted.
Firstly, the participation rate in the survey was low—permitting a head-to-head comparison between Ainslie and Desai only.
Here Are the Takeaways:
- Incumbent Paul Ainslie consistently voted with Mayor John Tory (and other right-leaning councillors), and took conservative positions on taxes and policing.
- Habiba Desai took similar positions as Ainslie on taxes, opposing additional property tax increases and the possible re-introduction of a personal vehicle tax; on housing, Desai differs from Ainslie in her support for more affordable housing units for the Housing Now initiative and a restriction on above guideline rent increases for those units.
Read Our Election Stories:
Toronto Election 2022
Ongoing coverage of Toronto’s 2022 municipal election. In-depth features on the issues at stake, hyper-local coverage of competitive ward races across the city, and a Candidate Tracker tool to keep you informed this fall.
Everything You Need to Know About School Trustees
We don’t elect people to oversee any other specific public service. But maybe we should?
Call the Police… Then Wait
The Toronto Police take three times longer than they should to get to the most urgent emergencies. Why a $1.1 billion force doesn’t come when you need them.
Pulled Off Wheel-Trans and Forced onto the Subway
Cost-cutting measures will push thousands of paratransit users onto the TTC, with disabled and elderly riders forced into gruelling bus and subway trips.
How Toronto’s Councillors Became Nearly Unbeatable
The numbers don’t lie: this city’s incumbency advantage is the worst in North America.
City Council Candidates
Paul Ainslie - Incumbent
Paul Ainslie is the incumbent city councillor for Ward 24. Previously, he served as city councillor for Ward 43 — Scarborough East from 2006 to 2014 and was also an interim councillor for Ward 41 — Scarborough-Rouge River in 2006. He sits on several boards and committees, such as the Toronto Public Library Board and the Toronto Seniors Housing Corporation.
Ainslie is generally a centrist councillor whose voting record has often defied the usual downtown-progressive/suburban-conservative split. Originally on then-Mayor Rob Ford’s Executive Committee, Ainslie broke with the mayor—and other suburban councillors—in supporting light rail over a subway in Scarborough. He has increasingly aligned with Tory over the past two terms.
Ainslie has been a key proponent of making City data publicly accessible via Open Data, as well as other digital-related initiatives like livestreaming committee meetings and calling for fair e-book pricing.
Habiba Desai
Habiba Desai is a University of Toronto alumna who ran as an independent candidate in the 2021 federal election in the Toronto-Danforth riding. She placed eighth with 129 votes. Her platform includes free TTC fare (paid for by “converting the TTC into a social media platform with advertising revenue in the billions”) as well as women-only subway compartments at the front of trains for safety. For affordable housing, Desai says the “real issue” is that worker’s wages cannot keep up with inflation. She said she will work with provincial and federal representatives, but did not provide more detail. Desai says she would eliminate the use of guns among police officers. She also proposes converting Borden High School, a dormant public school building, into a fight school and sports complex, which she says would create a cultural shift in young men that would also be a form of crime prevention.
Vivian Parker
Little information about Vivian Parker is available online, other than a GoFund me that has raised $626 of its $40,000 goal. In an email to The Local, he included campaign materials which state that he spent years in the Canadian Army and that his campaign promises to include after-school programs, affordable daycare and parks “free from drugs” to address youth mental illness. Parker also wrote that as councillor he would push for more buses, the expansion of Scarborough subway extension beyond its current goals to include Kingston Road and Port Union areas of Scarborough, as well as “stall” property and business taxes as a pandemic recovery measure. Parker also said that he will increase police presence in the areas with “guns and crime” and work with “our handsome and beautiful women and men in blue.”
School Trustee Candidates
Malaravan Balachandran
Malaravan Balachandran describes himself as a former student of two TDSB schools, and says he is familiar with the Scarborough Guildwood community having grown up there. He has also been an active volunteer in the community, including on the Toronto Strong Neighbourhood Strategy Resident Advisory Committee from 2015 to 2017, and as president of the Rotary Club of Scarborough from 2016 to 2017. Balachandran’s top priority is to provide students access to after school programs, mental health support, breakfast programs and the technology to help them succeed.
Sushital Choudhury
Sushital Choudhury is the director of the Toronto Durgabari, a Bangladeshi Hindu temple he helped develop in 2009. Sushital wants to create policies that support racial equity, foster community relationships, and improve resource allocation and safety if elected.
Elizabeth Issac
Information about this candidate could not be found at time of publication.
Sulaman Karimi
While there is limited information online describing his campaign, Sulaman Karimi describes himself, according to his LinkedIn Profile, as a Fraud Analyst at RBC. He was also the financial officer of the Ontario Tech Accounting Association from 2019 to 2020 while undertaking his studies at Ontario Tech University.
Ann-Marie Moulton
Information about this candidate could not be found at time of publication.
Zakir Patel - Incumbent
Elected in 2018, Zakir Patel is the incumbent TDSB trustee for Ward 19. According to his trustee webpage, he has been a real estate broker for over 15 years and owns several distribution services. He appears to have once been a director-at-large for the Scarborough-Guildwood Federal Liberal Association. He believes access to nutritional programs and extracurricular activities in schools is vital. In 2020 and 2021, Patel campaigned for a local school, St. Margaret’s Public School, to be put on the Toronto District School Board’s priority list to receive provincial funding for significant building repairs. The Toronto & York Region Labour Council endorses Patel.
Nancy Crawford - Incumbent
Nancy Crawford is the incumbent TCDSB trustee for Ward 12, holding the position since 2010. Crawford has served as the vice-chair of the Toronto Catholic School Board. She was also appointed to the board of directors of the Ontario Catholic School Trustees’ in April 2022. In a submitted campaign profile for Beach Metro Community News, Crawford notes that prior to being elected, she worked in Human Resources for the City of Toronto for 30 years and also holds a Master’s degree in Education from OISE, University of Toronto. Notably, as a trustee in 2019, she voted against motions to include the terms ‘gender identity’ and ‘gender expression in the TCDSB’s code of conduct, proclaim June ‘Pride Month’, and fly the pride flag, all of which ultimately passed. According to her campaign website, Crawford describes herself as a strong advocate for Catholic education, building and programming improvements, and developing relationships with other elected representatives, among other priorities.
Grazia Cubellis
Information about this candidate could not be found at time of publication.
Benoit Fortin - Incumbent
Benoit Fortin is the incumbent trustee for Conseil scolaire Viamonde Ward 2 – Est. He has held office since 2018, and has been elected by acclamation in this year’s election given he was running unopposed. Fortin is the founding member and Vice President of Development in Africa and India of Skypower, which develops, funds and runs utility-scale renewable power projects internationally. He is also vice-president of the Association des conseils scolaires des écoles publiques de l’Ontario board of directors, which represents all French-language public school boards in the province. While there is limited information about his priorities, Fortin has commented publicly as vice-president of the board on the importance of keeping students in the francophone school system until grade 12 and of meeting the specific needs of a growing francophone community following an announcement of funding from the Ontario government to build a new school.
Daniel Martin
The City Clerk has voided the election for the MonAvenir school board in this ward. The election will not take place on October 24 and a by-election will be held at a later date.
Salah Rawdat
The City Clerk has voided the election for the MonAvenir school board in this ward. The election will not take place on October 24 and a by-election will be held at a later date. In an email to parents sent on October 21, Rawdat said he was ending his campaign. Read more about ineligible trustees running in French-language schools.
Paul Wilson
The City Clerk has voided the election for the MonAvenir school board in this ward. The election will not take place on October 24 and a by-election will be held at a later date. On October 21, Wilson notified the city clerk that he is not eligible to hold office. Read more about ineligible trustees running in French-language schools.
_____
Information in Candidate Tracker was compiled and written by The Local’s team of journalists and fact checkers. City council candidates were emailed a questionnaire asking for information about their history, experience, and plans. They were also surveyed about their stances on twelve key votes that took place in the 2018-22 council term. Not all candidates were reachable or responded. The Local also conducted its own research to independently source and verify information about each city council and school trustee candidate. If you’re a candidate whose information is not here, please email us at elections@thelocal.to. Last updated: October 22, 2022.
Contributors: Inori Roy, Ann Marie Elpa, Nikky Manfredi, Danielle Orr, H.G. Watson, Emma Buchanan, Dhriti Gupta, Zeahaa Rehman, Neville Park, Nicholas Hune-Brown, Tai Huynh, Craig Madho, Steve Combes, and Lia Mattacchione.
Local Journalism Matters.
We're able to produce impactful, award-winning journalism thanks to the generous support of readers. By supporting The Local, you're contributing to a new kind of journalism—in-depth, non-profit, from corners of Toronto too often overlooked.
Support